This type of consider has been extremely influential into the feminist philosophy. Such as, More youthful retains you to Spelman keeps definitively shown that gender reality try untenable (1997, 13). Mikkola (2006) contends this isn’t therefore. The brand new arguments Spelman tends to make do not weaken the theory there is some feature function, experience, common condition otherwise expectations that describes ladies gender; they simply say that some sort of method of cashing aside what describes womanhood is actually mistaken. Therefore, regardless of if Spelman excellent so you can refute those people membership one falsely need this new function you to criteria light center-category Western feminists’ gender to help you reputation ladies’ gender in general, it departs open the chance that feminine qua women do show a thing that represent their gender. (Select as well as Haslanger [2000a] to own a dialogue of why gender realism is not necessarily untenable, and you may Stoljar to own a discussion off Mikkola’s criticism regarding Spelman.)

(más…)